1960's recipes Archives - Page 2 of 4 - Retro Food For Modern Times

Category: 1960’s recipes

09
Sep
2021

Pieathalon 8 – Ozark Pie

categories: 1960's recipes, Cook A Long, Pieathalon

Friends and pie lovers, it’s that wonderful time of year when food bloggers from all over the world celebrate the beauty of old-time pie by swapping recipes! And this year my pie came from S.S over at A Book of Cookrye, Ozark Pie! The timing was exceptional because I has been looking for a new show to watch and Ozark Pie was just the push I needed to start binging the Netlix show Ozark.

It’s always nerve wracking to see what pie you get. There’s always a fear that it might be something utterly horrible.

But as with the last recipe I got from SS, this one was an absolutel belter. So without any further preamble

Now, you may be wondering what is an Ozark Pie? Well for a start it’s not really a pie. It’s a very thick batter mixed with apples and nuts. I used walnuts but the recipe doesn’t specify so you can use what you like, or what you have.

I was going to start bitching here about weird measurements by the cup are for things like apples and walnuts but…

This was 2 small apples:

Now let’s get back to that batter. It was STIFF. I could barely stir it, And trying to mix the apples and walnuts into it was hard work!! But I eventually managed to get it somewhat mixed and into the pie dish. The result was not pretty!

Up close it was even worse. It looked liked a plate of sick…

Hmm…yes, but how? I put it in the oven and hoped that the magic alchemy is cooking would turn this toad into a prince.

But…about twenty minutes into the cook, something did start to happen. First there was a glorious smell of baked apples and sugar and….pie!!!!

And a few minutes later look what came out of the oven!

The batter was just the right level of sweet, the apples were juicy, the walnuts were toasty!!!!

We loved this pie! It was really delicious and very simple to make.

Shame not everyone felt the same way!

Ozark Pie – The Recipe

Well, for those of you who do not prefer French Toasts Sticks, here’s the recipe:

Thanks to SS for the fab recipe and Yinzerella for organising! Why not head over to see what they, and all the other Pieathletes cooked up! Also make sure to swing by Vintage Recipe Cards to see how my pick of Rum and Butterscotch Pie turned out!

The Pieathletes

(at the time of posting this list is incomplete and some of the links don’t work. I’ll refresh and add over the next day or so because it is now nearly the end of my day but many of the athletes will only be waking up about now)

Rum and Butterscotch Pie at Vintage Recipe Cards
Surprise Fudge Pie at Silver Screen Suppers
Tarte a l’Orange at Recipes for Rebels
Chocolate-Crusted Coffee Pie at Grannie Pantries
Osgood Pie at A Book of Cookrye
Tarte au Petite Suisse at The Nostalgic Cook
Save Your Marriage Meat Pie by Dr Bobb
Mahogany Pie from Dinner is Served 1972

Have a great week friends, and remember…eat pie!

05
Sep
2021

The Mystery of American Sardine Toasts

categories: 1960's recipes, Daily News, Fish, Sandwiches, Sardines

A recipe from The Daily News Cookbook called American Sardine Toasts caught my eye recently. Without wanting to labour the point too much, we Melbourrnians recently spent our 200th (non-consecutive) day in lockdown which means I have now been working from home for around 18 months. I have also recently been working all the hours so my need for quick and easy meals, be they work from home lunches or speedy suppers when I am too tired to cook has become paramount.

And this could well be the recipe that gets me through! Oh, and Uber Eats, but you’re not here to hear me talk about my local Thai!

In case you are wondering what an American Sardine Toast is? It’s kind of a tuna melt but with sardines.

As soon as I read the recipe, I constructed a narrative in my head which went a little like this. Someone in what was then Ceylon had travelled to America and had a tuna melt. They had then brought the concept back home – except maybe 1960’s Ceylon did not have access to canned tuna so they used what they had – sardines! And no doubt the local newspaper, The Daily News, was keen to publish a recipe from the country that epitomised all things new and bright and shiny and voila the recipe for American Sardine Toasts or as they call it, Sardine Toasts, American came into being

Except….DJ….cue the X Files Spooky Music.

The Mystery

According to writer Warren Bobrow, the tuna melt was invented in 1965 in Charleston, South Carolina. But the recipe for American Sardine Toasts appears in my mum’s 1964 edition of the Daily News Cookery Book! There’s definitely something fishy about that!

So if not based on the tuna melt, what is this recipe based on? What makes it an American Sardine Toast instead of just a regular sardine toast?

I even wondered if I was reading the name incorrectly. Instead of the Sardine Toasts being American was it that the sardines came from America? So not American (Sardine Toasts) but (American Sardine) Toasts? The actual name Sardine Toasts, American would indicate the former but who knows with this book! Sadly the American provenance of these toasts has been lost to history.

Luckily for us, the actual recipe has not and these hit the spot of being quick, easy and delicious and so will go on heavy

The Recipes

Yes, recipes! I took the OG recipe and modernised it to make it easier for WFH lunches. It also works well as a light supper too.

Here’s the original:

And here’s my version:

American Sardine Toasts

Print Recipe

A quick and easy alternative to a tuna melt!

Author: Taryn Nicole

Ingredients

Scale

2 slices of toast

Butter

1 can of sardines in tomato sauce

1/4 red onion, finely chopped

80g grated cheddar cheese

I tbsp finely chopped parsley

Salt and pepper

Cook Mode Prevent your screen from going dark

Instructions

Lightly butter the pieces of toast

Place 2 sardines on each piece of toast, making sure you get some of the tomato sauce from the can as well.

Sprinkle some chopped onion on top of the sardines.

Sprinkle the cheese over the top.

Place under a grill (180C) for 5 minutes or until the cheese has melted.

Season with salt and pepper.

Sprinkle the chopped parsley over the top.

Cut each piece of toast in two.

Eat immediately!

Have a great week!

25
Jul
2021

Cowboy Day – Pepsi Cola Cake with Broiled Peanut Butter Frosting

categories: 1960's recipes, Cake, Cook A Long, Cowboy Day

Yippee Ky Yay Cake Lovers, number 5 is alive!!!! This weekend, courtesy of the nicest man on the Internet, Greg Swenson, we are celebrating Cowboy Day with a Cookalong. I have chosen to bake a cake (because every celebration needs one) from Greg’s book, Recipes for Rebels: In The Kitchen with James Dean – and oh (cow)boy, what a cake it is. Pepsi Cola Cake with Broiled Peanut Butter Frosting.

You might be wondering what is the connection between a cake made from Pepsi and Cowboys? Well, hear me out here. It is a little like one of those puzzles you used to do at school where you change one letter at a time to turn one word into another…

But here me out:

James Dean played a cowboy in the film Giant
James Dean’s first paid acting job was in a Pepsi Commercial
Pepsi is a key ingredient in this cake.

Cowboy to cake in less steps than it will take you to go from bath to tubs!

Good lord, just look at that face!!! If that is not a textbook definition of impossibly handsome, I do not know what is.

Something that is most definitely not impossibly handsome is the Pepsi-Cola Cake. It is a massive brute of a thing (might one say a Giant?) that erupted like a volcano in my oven. It reminded me of the ads we used to have for Picnic bars – deliciously ugly.

I mean, ok, it doesn’t look quite as much like a pooh as a Picnic bar but at the point of removal from the oven, it did not look good.

But as the picnic ad states that’s what wrappers are for. And the wrapping on the Pepsi-cola cake is some divine Peanut Butter frosting.

I mean it’s still not the prettiest cake in the world. But, do not let it’s somewhat less than gorgeous faced fool you. Remember the delicious part of deliciously ugly? Well this cake has a ton of delicious! The cake itself is moist and fudgy, a little like a brownie. The slight slatiness in the peanut butter frosting is a perfect accompaniment to the sweetness of the cake. Beware though the Pepsi Cake is not just rich. It is filthy rich!!!

I have a sweet tooth and even I would recommend cutting what you think is a normal-sized slice of cake then cutting that in two. And bada bing bada boom that’s elevenses and afternoon tea sorted!!!!

Pepsi Cola Cake – Recipe

So, the recipe for this cake made me laugh. I love the way they ask for non-sweetened cocoa powder. I mean, when you already have 2 cups of sugar and a cup of Pepsi in your cake I guess you have to draw the line somewhere.

Here’s the recipe!

This was so much fun! I loved cooking this cake and being able to take part in the world wide cookalong to celebrate Cowboy Day 2021! Thank you Greg for organising and inviting me to contribute!

Have a great week everyone!!!!

03
Sep
2020

Chicken Salad Pie – Pieathalon 7

categories: 1960's recipes, Bad Retro Food, Chicken, Cook A Long, Pie, Pieathalon

Hello friends and pie eaters!!! Welcome to Pieathalon 7 – that very special time of year when bloggers from all over the world get together and celebrate the weird and wonderful world of vintage pies. And oh boy did it get weird this year! Surly over from at Vintage Recipe Cards sent me a hybrid concoction which much like my detested chocolate cheesecake takes two things that separately are wonderful and combines them into a Franken-monster Chicken Salad Pie!

Are you ready, are you ready for this? Are you hanging on the edge of your seat?

Glorious is it not?

Before we even get to the eating of it, let me tell you that Chicken Salad Pie was an absolute BASTARD of a thing to make! Even before that though, let’s start with possibly the only positive to come out of this which is the perfect late ’60’s styling of the original recipe! Perfection! I want that leaf plate so, so much. And those gold glasses!

So, you’ll notice that my pies are a lot more round that those in the recipe. Let me tell you why.

Chicken Salad Pie: Hours 1-3

I finished work at around 6 and started cooking. Given that I now mostly work from the dining table, I probably started making the Chicken Salad Pie at around…6:01. Put the chicken on to poach. Start cutting the pastry into the right size of rounds. Oh, yeah, did I mention I was doing this on the Tuesday night before we posted today?

6:30: Everything on track. The chicken was poached and was cooling. The pastry had been blind-baked and was also cooling.

6:45 The broth, salad dressing, onion, lemon juice and salt were in the bowl waiting for the pimentos. Oh. That’s right. We don’t have pimentos here. So, in order to get pimentos, I bought a jar of stuffed olives and picked them out of the olives using a kitchen skewer.

How long does it take to pick out a peck of pickled pimentos?

Too damn long.

Especially if you eat half the olives you are meant to be picking.

7:15: Pimentos were picked. Gelatine was added. Mixture was beaten and left to chill.

8:15: Has the mixture thickened? I don’t think it’s thickened. Better give it another half hour.

8:45: The mixture has definitely not thickened.

8:50: Research what do to if gelatine does not set.

Chicken Salad Pie: Hours 3-6

9:00. Tip the mixture into a saucepan and heat it. Add more gelatin.

9:20: Place mixture back into the fridge. Wonder why you chose this week of all weeks to be alcohol-free.

9:45: Mixture shows no sign of thickening. But it was warm so it will probably take longer right?

10:15 Still not thickening. Realise you have not had dinner. Eat some olives.

10:45 It’s like water. Pour runny gelatine back into the saucepan.

11:15 Add more gelatine to the rewarmed mixture. Have a glass of wine. This is not the week to quit drinking.

11:30 Put the mixture back into the fridge. Curse the non-specificity of vintage recipes. How much gelatine was in an envelope of gelatine in 1968? And how does that translate to spoonfuls which is how I am measuring mine. Wonder why you leave everything to the last minute. Vow to change. Eat more olives.

Midnight: The mixture is thickening!!!! REEEEE-SULT! Add the chicken and celery

12:15: Still thickening but still too runny to pour into the pie shells. Because as they keep telling you on The Great British Bake-off, no one likes a soggy bottom! Decide to pour the mixture into teacups, allow it to set inside them and turn them out ~~the following day~~….later that same day.

CHICKEN SALAD PIE – THE VERDICT

Cutting into the chicken salad pie was reminiscent of cutting into that jellied loaf style of dog food which was a real hurdle to overcome when tasting it. I did have a tiny bit and it wasn’t….awful. It tasted and smelled mostly of the dressing. But the association with dogfood was enough to prevent me from eating any more.

So in summary, no sleep, no dinner and a pie that looked like Pedigree Chum. It was certainly no winner, winner chicken dinner. I can’t even feed it to the dogs, who would love it due to the onions! This one, sadly, is going straight into the trash.

Pieathalon 7

Thanks as ever to Yinzerella for organising Pieathalon 7! You’re the best!

Thanks / Curses to Surly for the recipe. It was very fun to make despite it taking forever and being the closest thing to dogfood I have ever eaten.

I really hope Wendy from A Day In The Life on The Farm fared better with my recipe for Cherry Blossom Pie!

To see how Wendy went and to check out all the other pies, please click on the links below. If they are not all up at the time of posting, I will update during the course of the day.

Yinzerella from Dinner is Served 1972 made a Betty Crocker Sombrero Pie. Ole!
Camilla went on a culinary adventure with a Lattice Pineapple Pie
Dr Bobb cooked an Empenada Pescado? Marisco? Mariscada? Something like that anyway!
Kelly from The Velveteen Lounge whipped up a Chocolate Mint and Prune Pie. Fresh breath and healthy bowels!
SS from A Book Of Cookrye made a honey of a Honey Fruit Pie
Batterburg Belle from Kitchen Confidence treated us to a Sour Cream Apricot Pie. Sounds delish!
Jenny from Silver Screen Suppers celebrated with a Party Pink Pie.
Surly from Vintage Recipe Cards made a Crumb Pie. It would be crumby of me not to wish her well. Even though she sent me dogfood pie.
Kari from the The Nostalgic cook made Lemon Pie Reliable. I hope it was Kari!
Poppy Crocker from Grannie Panties made Avocado Lime Pie. I’m there for it!
Judy from the Book Club Cookbook made Pumpkin Pie with a Secret. But don’t tell anyone!
Greg from Recipes4Rebels made an Apple Crumb Pie. Let’s hope it was (red) delicious

Okay friends, stay safe and most importantly…eat pie!

10
Feb
2020

Devilled Cashew Nuts

categories: 1960's recipes, Cashew Nuts, Nuts, Snacks, Sri Lanka

Helloooo friends! Ttoday’s recipe is nuts! But not just any nuts. These are devilled cashew nuts and damn they are the tastiest, most more-ish little morsels around!

The recipe for my devilled cashew nuts is based on a recipe from The Daily News Cookery Book. First published in 1929, this book is probably the book of Sri Lankan cooking. It’s also bonkers in parts. I have two copies of the Daily News Cookery book – one that was given to my mum as a wedding present and a new version that I bought in Sri Lanka a few years ago. I would have loved to do a Julia and Julia cook through of this book but there are ingredients I would not be able to get hold of and some of the measurements are based on weird Sri Lankan things that no longer exist. Chhudu anyone? So I might take you all on a limited express rather than a stopping all stations journey through this book.

These devilled cashew nuts ( or cadjunuts as Sri Lankans call them) are relatively straightforward to make so are a good introduction to this book.

They are also a great little snack, but when combined with a beverage? PER-FEC-TION!!! 😍

Here is the recipe from the Daily News.

The recipe calls for ground saffron. I tried to do this but I only had a small bit of saffron and it just disappeared into nothing while I was grinding it. So, what I did was to soak the saffron in a small dish of warm water and then, after about 20 minutes, I tipped the saffrony flavoured water over the nuts. I’m sure this activated them or some such too. I let them soak in the saffron water for about 4 hours then tipped them onto a sheet of paper towels and let them dry for around the same amount of time.

Once dry, I rubbed in salt and cayenne pepper and then followed the recipe to cook them. If you were in a hurry, you could grind the saffron as per the recipe or leave it out.

The smell of the toasting cashews was heavenly!

And eating them still warm from the pan was a moment of pure joy! It was hard to save some for my cocktail but, it was going to be a long while between drinks as I am doing dry February so I did my best to save a few for the sipping. And it was worth it!

Match made in heaven!

I’ll post the cocktail recipe separately but damn it was good too!

These Devilled Cashew Nuts are so easy to make and definitely something you’ll go nuts for

Enjoy!

And have a great week,